Movie warning
In case you've been interested in seeing The Holiday, please let me advise you to think again. It's bad. It's so bad. I can't even believe there is a movie featuring Kate Winslet that I dislike so violently, but there is. The only person who acquits himself decently in this movie is Jude Law, of all people. He's very warm, funny, and likeable. He should abandon his eternal character actor quest and just start starring in every romantic comedy and accept that it is his destiny. The rest of them are just kind of idiots. In what universe are we supposed to believe that Kate Winslet is pining hopelessly for Rufus Sewell? The Rufus Sewell of Dangerous Beauty, possibly, but not the strange Rufus Sewell of modern times, the one who always plays a cad or a murderer and looks like he's had a botched eye job. Poor Kate. This was just not a good part for her. Cameron Diaz is ridiculous. She was as plastic as Jude Law was genuine and engaging. Jack Black tried, it seemed, to scale back the Jack Blackness, but it's impossible for him, I think. Luckily I think Jack Black is pretty funny, and I enjoyed his singing of the movie scores in the video store. But so many parts of this movie made me cringe or want to nod off because it just dragged on forever. I had high hopes for it despite its generally poor reviews, including my sister's, who warned me that it was terrible, not only because of Kate but because Nancy Meyers also wrote and directed what I think is one of the best romantic comedies of the last ten years, Something's Gotta Give. That movie is better than The Holiday by leaps and bounds, almost unfathomably. So please, spare yourself. Other than making me want to go to England when it's snowing, this movie was a giant waste of time. Skip it.

10 Comments:
Oh my God it is so, so bad that I started to clean my nails, rather than finish watching it.
(I love it when we agree on movies!)
i hear the movie has nicely-designed sets!
I forced poor S. (my roommate! the author!) to go see this on my birthday. And he still talks to me. Isn't he lovely?
Erin -- I was worried after our fundamental disagreement on The Last Kiss. I thought you might have lost your movie-loving mind. Phew. Anonymous -- the sets were very nice, definitely. The movie was great to look at, but that's about it. Patsy -- I like how you give S. descriptions now so I can keep him straight. Please continue to do so with all of the men in your life. Why, WHY did this movie have to be so bad? I really wanted to like it.
I saw this in the movie theatre and after forty-five minutes I wanted to flush my head in the toilet. It was so gawd-awful horrible. Like you, I could not fathom Kate Winslet's character pining after Jasper. And gawd, how I detested Cameron Diaz. She was so annoying and I did not believe for one second she was a big shot Hollywood producer. Jude Law's character was sweet, but goodness, I saw his whole story coming from a mile away.
The only parts I did like were the elderly neighbor and Cameron's fabulous Hollywood house!
But, Eliza, Something's Gotta Give was terrible, too. To think Diane Keaton used to be one of my favorite actresses. Enough already with the turtlenecks. Jack was a big ham. And Keanu, well....Let's just say I expected better from the whole lot.
Oh, man, I couldn't agree more with your review. I rented The Holiday as a guilty Netflix pleasure, but it was apparent from the very beginning that I was watching a disaster film. It made my head hurt. I wanted to deliver a massive Charlie's Angel-style kick to Cameron Diaz's midsection throughout the whole thing.
And I've got your back on Something's Gotta Give. It's not exactly Gandhi, but a pretty watchable and enjoyable romantic comedy. Basically, the opposite of The Holiday.
Rudy -- you're not the only one who questions my judgement on Something's Gotta Give. My sister also strongly dislikes it.
romanlily ... it's funny that you mention the Charlie's Angel's kick ... because in an interview in the DVD special features, Cameron Diaz says that The Holiday is the most physical movie she's ever done. (Insert clips of her spazzing out and running in The Holiday.) Which makes not a whole lot of sense considering that she did two Charlie's Angels movies. Maybe she was being sarcastic? I don't even pretend to know.
Oh come on, Eli Wallach rocks and at least it's the first movie in the history of the world that features old people where none of them die. That in itself is worth something.
anonymous -- come on, people, just put a name! -- totally agreed that Eli Wallach rocks.
Post a Comment
<< Home